A few weeks ago I attended the funeral of PawPaw’s Aunt JoAnn who was killed in an automobile wreck in Georgia. Three ministers officiated at the service - two men and one woman. I was struck with how comforting and spiritual the woman minister was.
After the innumerable arguments in comments here at TMS about women ministers - with the COC folks declaring that it is anti-scriptural and wrong, I guess I am very sensitive to the whole issue. Well, and the fact that my mother is a minister. Whenever I’m around a woman minister - such as at JoAnn’s funeral - I observe carefully to see if there’s a hint of arrogance or of trying to push her way into a previously all-male world. I try to figure out her motivation and purpose. I’ve had significant interactions with three women ministers, and all three have been positive interactions.
The COC folks who’ve commented here have written that males and females have their mutually exclusive roles, and any position of service in a church where a woman might possibly lead Christian men is forbidden. Of course their male domination extends beyond just the ministry. It seems amazingly arrogant to not only discount what one could learn from half the population but to also limit what God can do through the ministry of women.
The minister at the funeral was named Melissa.  She gave the main eulogy - talking about JoAnn’s life and sharing little anecdotes about JoAnn. Her message was one of honoring JoAnn’s life as she told about how JoAnn grew up, married Ansley and how she loved God and her family - how she lived a life of service to others. Before and after the service she was at JoAnn and Ansley’s home, visiting with the family and providing comfort and guidance.
Later I overheard PawPaw’s mother remark to someone that she’s never been much in favor of women ministers, but after hearing Melissa speak at the funeral and watching her as she interacted with the family, she would like having her for a minister. I’ve seen the same thing happen in churches where my mother was a minister. Once people experience having a woman as their minister, they realize the narrowness of believing that God can only work through men as ministers.
I guess if a person has never been around women ministers, it would be easy to say that it’s wrong and to follow blindly the teachings of churches such as the COC. However, I can say unequivocably that God is working through the ministry of at least the three women ministers that I know, and the churches and the communities where they work are the better for it.
 I think my mother said it best when she said hers is not a ministry of authority but of service.
Sphere: Related Content
May 24th, 2006 at 7:42 am
Hi Carol,
I’ve been poking around your blog (when I should be working… shhhh)and had to stop to comment on this post. I’m not yet a full-fledged minister (more of an MIT) but I’ve encountered some ignoramuses online with regards to this topic. Traumatized me for a bit.
I’m glad to hear that your mom and the other women you know have been holding it down for us.
May 25th, 2006 at 9:12 pm
Carol,
I’m very glad your experience of women ministers seems to have been uniformly positive. My experience has been that, as a class—if I may be forgiven for making of women ministers a class *heh*—women ministers are no more or less likely to be good ministers, good preachers or, to be blunt, good Christians.
Unfortunately, those few who are poor exegetes, poor counselors, poor administrators, overbearing or whatever poor ministry skill or behavior can be jumped upon do seem to be pummelled a bit harder than men with the same failings.
*sigh*
It’s a complex subject, but easily rectified among those who take scripture seriously rather than taking their own eisegesis of scripture seriously:
“There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus…”
Yes, there are fairly well-defined roles for men and women in Christian culture—scripturally defined. But mixing church government and family government (and even there, I like stumping domineering men with scripture showing areas where their wife is to rule them *heh*) and reading specific injunctiuons to one church as generally applicable (while ignoring widespread scriptures that are contrary) and simply applying non-biblical cultural traditions lead many astray on the issue of women dacons/teachers/preachers/ministers/pastors.
Oh. Well.
May 25th, 2006 at 10:52 pm
Very well said Carol.
July 5th, 2007 at 7:09 am
David,
You just made a friend, made a friend. LOL.
Peace,
Dee
July 5th, 2007 at 2:55 pm
Thanks, Dee, David, and Beth - thanks for visiting and commenting.
February 16th, 2013 at 10:03 pm
Really great information can be found on website . “Often the test of courage is not to die but to live.” by Conte Vittorio Alfieri.