(For my March 8th predictions, click HERE)

Here are my predictions for who is going home on tonight’s American Idol show:


(1) Sanjaya Malakar – He’s got a nice voice, but he doesn’t have any qualities that make his voice noticeable.  His performance Tuesday night was too subdued – weak and childish.  I wonder who selected his songs because his song choices last week and this week were absolutely awful.  I can’t imagine worse songs for a competition than the ones he sang.

(2) Brandon Rogers – His voice just isn’t good enough, and I can’t even remember what he sang Tuesday night.  Totally forgetable.


(1) Antonella Barba – Her voice sounded weak and off-pitch.  She just doesn’t measure up to the standard of excellence of most of the other female singers.  However, her notoriety over the porn photos may have gotten her enough votes to stay another week or two.

(2) Alaina Alexander – Her voice simply isn’t unique.  She sounds like any other good singer in the world.  She’d make a good backup singer.  Wednesday night she just didn’t cut it, and her song choice was the pits.  You’d think she would have selected a song that really showcased her voice.  Instead she chose a controversial song with such negative associations that she immediately alienated half the audience.

Other possibilities: For the girls, I’d say that Haley Scarnato and Leslie Hunt could easily be voted off tonight. For the boys, I wouldn’t be surprised to see Nicholas Pedro go home.

My personal favorites are Jordin Sparks and Chris Sligh.

It’ll be interesting to see if I’m right.  I haven’t voted at all yet this season.  I just don’t care enough about any of the performers yet to make the effort to vote. 

Later note:  Well I got one out of four.  However, I don’t think the others I listed will last more than a couple weeks.  Time will tell.

Sphere: Related Content

8 Responses to “American Idol (March 1)- Who’s going home tonight?”

  1. Wild Bluff Media : Entertainment Examined Says:

    links from Technoratit forget to come back here! 501st Legion Inducts Kevin Smith as “friend” – HMTK: One of the writers over at HMTK got to meet both Kevin Smith and Stan Lee in one day at the same event. It just doesn’t seem fair!American Idol – Who’s going home tonight? – TheMedianSib: Carol and I had some very similar predictions earlier this week for American Idol. Her prediction skills were better than mine though. Two Books Every Blogger Should Read – The Real Ryan J. Parker: Ryan has offered up a couple of books on writing well

  2. Wacky Mommy Says:

    I’ve never watched the show until this season (believe it or not) but the kids and I have been enjoying it.

    Thanks for stopping by, and for keeping the Thursday Thirteen going. Really needed it this week (obviously). I’ll be back…

  3. Susan Says:

    I am so there for you on these…I’m watching now anxiously waiting to find out the answer.

    :-) Susan

  4. WildBluff_Matt Says:

    Arrghh. You were a lot closer than me on the ladies. But I can’t believe neither of those guys went home! Not surprised that much about Pedro, but why not Sanjaya??

  5. rackel Says:

    I hope Sanjaya goes home hes just not that good

  6. Mae Bayne Says:

    I really enjoyed the top 5 Idol group song last night. It was a pity to see Aaron Kelly eliminated but I do believe the other singers were better singers so he needed to go!

  7. Claud Chumbler Says:

    I saw American Idol winner Lee has recently signed up to RCA records. Cannot wait to listen to his upcoming album.

  8. Ariel Moffett Says:

    I believe Donald Trump would be a better American Idol judge than Harry Connick Jr. – Trump is not at all afraid to voice what he thinks and can be as outspoken as Simon Cowell.

Leave a Reply