Another night of American Idol. I”ll be blogging about it. So check back often for updates - at least every five minutes I’ll update what’s going on and what I think about it. I know there will be literally thousands of you who will be anxiously awaiting my thoughts and opinions about the contestants, their song choices and their performances. Yea! Another night of American Idol.
7:01 - The obligatory biography of Neil Diamond. Yawn.
7:06 - Jason Castro is up first. Each contestant will sing two songs, but they won’t be judged until after the second song. He’s singing “Forever in Blue Jeans” and “September Morn.”
“Forever in Blue Jeans” is the first one. I wonder why he’s singing in such a quiet voice. It’s about to put me to sleep. Let’s get a little enthusiasm in there, Jason!
My verdict: weak and uninspired.
7:12 - David Cook is up next. “I’m Alive” and “All I Need is You” - two fairly unfamiliar songs. Neil Diamond said “I got goose bumps” when David sang for him. First song is “I’m Alive.” It started out slow, but is getting better. Definitely getting better. I don’t think I’ve heard this song, but I like it.
My verdict: Not outstanding but better than average.
7:15 - Brooke White is next. Her two songs are “I’m A Believer” while she plays the guitar, and then “I Am, I Said” - playing the piano. First up - “I’m a Believer.” Her voice is kinda wavery tonight. Hmmm. I’m not being impressed.
My verdict: Nope - not inspiring at all. Totally forgetable.
7:21 - David Archuletta is up next. He’s singing “Sweet Caroline” and “America” I think he’s smart to select well known songs. “Sweet Caroline” is first. He’s definitely giving it his own spin.
My verdict: It was fair. Not outstanding but okay.
7:24 - Syesha is next: “Hello Again” and “Thank the Lord for the Nighttime.” With her Broadway style singing last week that got so much praise, I think she selected two good songs. “Hello Again” is first. What’s with all the folks down front swaying their arms back and forth. That looks so stupid, and they do it every week on any slow song. Well, Syesha is good but, again, forgettable.
My verdict: Sweet but boring.
7:28 - a quick assessment of the first round of songs. I agree 100% with what Simon said - which was basically what I wrote on my verdicts of each performance. Round 2 coming up after the commerical break.
Jason Castro: “September Morn” - Now THIS is truly a karaoke performance. I could use this performance as a sleep aid anytime. No emotion - b-o-r-i-n-g - a little pitchy at the end, too.
Randy: It was just okay. That was just another okay whatever performance - definitely not the best
Paula: I feel like it’s safe and you need to get out of your comfort zone
Simon: We don’t recognize you at the moment. You struggled through both songs. I think both songs were forgettable.
David Cook: “All I Need Is You” - Very slow start. I sure hope this gets better. RT’s comment: “I ain’t impressed!” I agree. Hmmm. Not impressive at all.
Randy: Again, you rocked the house again tonight.
Paula: I’m so proud of you…I feel like I”m already looking at the American Idol
Simon: I thought the first song was okay. I thought the second song was brilliant.
(I TOTALLY disagree. I thought the performance was a yawner)
Brooke White: “I Am, I Said”. I liked it.
Randy: Nice job!
Paula: It shows your vulnerability. That just works.
Simon: I really really hated the first song. This is the Brooke we like - sitting behind the piano singing a good song. It wasn’t incredible but it was a million times better than the first song.
David Archelleta: “America” Again, definitely his own take on the song. I like this.
Randy: For a young man, you’re definitely in the zone now.
Paula: This was the absolute perfect song for you to sing. I love you. You’re brilliant.
Simon: THAT was a smart choice of song. Check, check, check. Very good.
Syesha Mercado: “Thank the Lord for the Nighttime” I’m not being impressed with this.
Randy: I think you’ve finally realized who you are. That’s also in the zone.
Paula: First song - that’s your magic. Second song - that’s you theater performance place
Simon: You are a very good actress/singer. I think, however, you may be in trouble tonight.
I think either Jason or Syesha will go home tomorrow night.
Sphere: Related Content