Comments on: Hate Crimes - Aren’t ALL crimes hate crimes? http://themediansib.com/2007/04/23/hate-crimes-arent-all-crimes-hate-crimes/ Sat, 22 Nov 2008 00:34:18 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.1 By: David http://themediansib.com/2007/04/23/hate-crimes-arent-all-crimes-hate-crimes/#comment-43587 David Tue, 24 Apr 2007 02:26:41 +0000 http://themediansib.com/2007/04/23/hate-crimes-arent-all-crimes-hate-crimes/#comment-43587 No, not all crimes are "hate" crimes. Take for example the typical behavior of congresscritters or Mass Media Podpeople. Surely their daily criminal behavior is motivated more by greed than by hate? *heh* Of course, murder and other crimes of violence are frequently motivated by "hate" but as often crimes of violence are motivated by greed or simple temporary anger or other motivations. That is why separating some crimes out as "hate" crimes is, well, hateful. It says that the murder of someone done for reasons of greed (robbery, inheritance, whatever) is somehow less heinous than the murder of someone because of an attitudinal issue in the perpetrator that can be characterized as "hateful". Then there's the thought crime aspect. We tread very close to 1984 with the view that the <i>thoughts</i> a person thinks are somehow worse than the actions they take. But really, that's the point of this "hate crime" push: creating a class of "thought crimes"--a natural thing for people who want to exercise cradle to grave control over people's lives. For when thoughts become crimes, only criminals will think... No, not all crimes are “hate” crimes. Take for example the typical behavior of congresscritters or Mass Media Podpeople. Surely their daily criminal behavior is motivated more by greed than by hate?

*heh*

Of course, murder and other crimes of violence are frequently motivated by “hate” but as often crimes of violence are motivated by greed or simple temporary anger or other motivations. That is why separating some crimes out as “hate” crimes is, well, hateful. It says that the murder of someone done for reasons of greed (robbery, inheritance, whatever) is somehow less heinous than the murder of someone because of an attitudinal issue in the perpetrator that can be characterized as “hateful”.

Then there’s the thought crime aspect. We tread very close to 1984 with the view that the thoughts a person thinks are somehow worse than the actions they take.

But really, that’s the point of this “hate crime” push: creating a class of “thought crimes”–a natural thing for people who want to exercise cradle to grave control over people’s lives. For when thoughts become crimes, only criminals will think…

]]>
By: Joan http://themediansib.com/2007/04/23/hate-crimes-arent-all-crimes-hate-crimes/#comment-43560 Joan Mon, 23 Apr 2007 20:06:35 +0000 http://themediansib.com/2007/04/23/hate-crimes-arent-all-crimes-hate-crimes/#comment-43560 That is exactly what I ask every time I hear that ridiculous expression. That is exactly what I ask every time I hear that ridiculous expression.

]]>